Study shows virtual reality could hold the key to GPs spotting child abuse
A three-year research project led by University College London and Goldsmiths has indicated that virtual reality (VR) could become a vital tool for training General Practitioners (GPs) to look out for hard-to-detect signs of child abuse.
In an article published today in ‘Frontiers in Robotics and AI’, which covers all theory and applications of robotics, technology, and artificial intelligence, a team of academics led by Professor Sylvie Delacroix, Professor in Law and Ethics who has now moved to the University of Birmingham, sets out that VR has a very important role to play in helping GPs to further develop the wide range of intuitive and perceptual skills that are essential to their practice.
While some of those skills can be taught pretty straightforwardly, others are harder to teach without the benefit of experience and role models. The ability to pick up signs that a child may be suffering from abuse at home is one of those skills that cannot easily be taught.
The project looked at how an immersive virtual reality environment could address these challenges.
Dr Sylvia Xueni Pan of Goldsmiths, University of London led the development of an immersive virtual reality environment replicating a GP’s surgery, where GP participants were able to interact with virtual, avatar patients in the same way as they would in a ‘real’ consultation.
In the virtual scenario, the GP encountered a patient with a complex medical condition. He was accompanied by his son, whom he treated so aggressively as to cause the son to flinch. The tell-tale signals of child abuse were made more subtle in one condition, and more obvious in the other, with expert advice provided by Dr Caroline Fertleman (UCL), a paediatrician with particular expertise in child-safeguarding.
All the characters were animated using motion capture data captured from professional actors. This animation and dialogue elements were then integrated into the animation engine.
A total of 64 GPs with different levels of experience were involved in the study. Its aim was to establish whether levels of experience would have any impact on the GPs’ ability to pick up child-safeguarding concerns, and whether more experienced GPs would find it easier to pick up subtle, rather than obvious, signs of child-safeguarding concerns.
The project’s main measurement was the quality of the note left by the GP at the end of the virtual consultation. These notes were reviewed by a panel of 10 with relevant training in safeguarding, to reflect the fact that there is no single right answer when it comes to child-safeguarding strategies. This panel rated the note according to the extent to which they were able to identify and take the necessary steps required in relation to the child safeguarding concerns.
Professor Delacroix says, ‘It is very difficult to study how GPs spot signs of abuse, given the number of factors that may interfere with this in a real-life, professional setting. It is encouraging that the system developed by this project showed that the GPs’ level of experience did not impact upon their ability to pick up on a parent’s level of aggressive behaviour towards their child.
‘Our results also showed that GPs who are less stressed, less neurotic, more agreeable and extroverted tend to be better at raising potential child abuse issues in their notes. These results not only indicate the considerable potential of virtual reality as a training tool – they also highlight fruitful avenues for further research and potential strategies to support GPs in their dealing with highly sensitive, emotionally charged situations.’
The VR lead of the work, Dr Sylvia Xueni Pan of Goldsmiths, says: “An advantage of our approach is that, unlike with actors, we have absolute control over our virtual characters. This means we can subtly alter the behaviour and responses of these virtual patients. Our results show that medical doctors responded to this, as those given less obvious behavioural cues were not as effective at recording concerns as those given more obvious cues.”
The medical lead of the work, Dr Caroline Fertleman from UCL says: “For ethical reasons it would be impossible to recreate this kind of sensitive scenario using child actors. What we have shown, for the first time, is that we can create virtual reality characters of abused children and their parents that doctors believe in and interact with in a realistic way enabling them to learn how to spot the subtle warning signs of abuse.”
For a full version of the paper Full version of the published study
I love the way our names have changed to be linguistically appropriate!
|Please describe how the nominee demonstrates the values of a medical educator and promotes the aims and objectives of the Academy of Medical Educators
I would like to nominate Caroline for this award in recognition of her exceptional achievement as a medical educator. She demonstrates an understanding of the values important to her role and an active demonstration of them in all her educational activity. Her work is outward facing; that is; she works inclusively and transparently to support individuals and teams to work collaboratively, thereby optimising their performance, productivity and achievement.
Half her time is dedicated to educational activity (the remainder being clinical work), during which Caroline supports a whole range of individuals from school leavers to senior colleagues and leads a number of education-based teams locally, regionally and nationally. She supports and leads these individuals to deliver high quality educational output: in 2015 she was senior author on 13 peer reviewed publications in the field of Medical Education and in 2016 has another nine. These articles showcase over 30 doctors in training whose work she has supported from inception to final publication. Caroline’s ability to motivate, engage and work inclusively is a key component of her approach.
Caroline is very familiar with curriculum development and I shall highlight this with two examples. Along with the first UCL Academic Clinical Fellow in Medical Education, for whom she acted as Supervisor, Caroline led the development of the new national undergraduate paediatric curriculum, launched last year. Throughout the process, she proactively engaged stakeholders including all 32 UK medical schools, the GMC, the Medical Schools Council and the RCPCH. She ensured the inclusion of a wide range of individuals, including parents, medical students and clinical teachers in the Delphi process underpinning the curriculum development. Several medical schools are already using this open source material to replace existing curricula, demonstrating successful promotion and dissemination of best practice.
Caroline has led on development of the UK’s first and only iBSc programme in Paediatrics and Child Health. She has led the now most popular iBSc at UCL for seven years. Through her leadership the teaching fellows have undertaken individual projects resulting in international presentations and contributing towards textbooks. The students too have had a huge number of peer review publications from their projects. Students have told Caroline that they had specifically chosen UCL because of this iBSc and the team have made a major impact on the iBSc programme and continue to push UCL to the forefront in specialist paediatric undergraduate training. This novel course incorporates innovative teaching, reflection and assessment to foster long term learning and good medical practice. I include a concrete example of innovation in this iBSc. Patient journeys are a fabulous way to teach and learn. As part of the assessment, students annotate a patient journey. They gather an in-depth case and provide pointers in the narrative to consider. These journeys are used in the subsequent year’s cohort in a small group setting led by a consultant child and adolescent psychiatrist and teaching fellow as a starting point to consider these diverse and challenging issues. These journeys are published this year in a book (CRC press).
Caroline won a much coveted UCL provost teaching award in April 2017.
The application was based on this both a description of Caroline’s teaching-related practice (written in the first person)
I am applying for this education award in recognition of my outward-facing work. Recent studies have explored how new types of communication, in the context of supportive relationships, can enhance performance and productivity. Using an outward-facing approach, I have built transparent systems that promote individuals whilst supporting teams to work collaboratively. I support a variety of individuals from school leavers to senior colleagues and lead a number of teams locally, regionally and nationally. My time is split equally undertaking paediatric clinical work and educational activities. Since 2015, I am pleased to report the following; I have had 21 peer review publications (marked #) as last author showcasing 30 colleagues, launched a national undergraduate paediatric curriculum, won the BMA best paediatric textbook prize, was awarded Senior Fellowship of the Higher Education Academy (HEA), won a UCL School of Life and Medical Sciences teaching award and the Presidents Medal from the Academy of Medical Education (AoME). Continue reading Provost Teaching Award
We are a 22 individual doctors and medical students who wish to collectively nominate Dr Caroline Fertleman for Trainer of the Year Award.
Caroline’s passion for medical education is infectious, particularly her ability to turn any situation into a chance to learn. She is very proactive about sharing learning and engaging people and not only provides a great deal of excellent teaching herself but also inspires others to pursue their interest in medical education. Continue reading UCLP trainer of the year award
Women of The Whitt – 100 Years of Women in Medicine
– A conference organised by Caroline Fertleman.
What did you like most about this conference?
The keynote speakers had very well established careers, very interesting to hear how their journey
Very friendly and positive, lots of inspirational women keynote speakers. Listening to women who feel you can have it all, personal career progression stories.
Keynote talks were inspiring. A good reminder of why we should be activated and get actively involved in making change.
It was very informative and inspirational, all the keynote speakers were very inspirational and great role models.
An opportunity to meet and speak to a variety of different professionals and hear about their experiences.
Senior doctors sharing their stories really puts human sides to the face and allocates. Real role models.
The opportunity to share with and listen to the experiences of colleagues at all levels of training
Why did you attend?
To consider how to be more resilient, that it’s ok to want to do other things as a doctor
Options in academic medicine ways to deal with negative feelings, different specialities.
Saw an opportunity to learn more about life outside of clinical medicine as well as career options specifically aimed at women.
Line up sounded exciting, something new and different
Discovering the role of women in the NHS
Interest in gender and women, particularly women in medicine
What key learning points did you take away?
Helpful to empower each other
“make the mould fit you” – don’t have to achieve consultancy in a set order or by a set time.
Great young women doctors
Your career doesn’t have to follow the normal pathway. How to approach difficult matters and develop resilience.
Women’s issues and how people in senior roles are affected ie. Childcare. Hearing about women in medicine
Flexibility is a right
That it is possible to manage work and home life with success. Most of all, that it is ok to have doubts and not feel like medicine has to be my #1 calling in life.
What the role of an active medic is and what the career progression is like, speed dating was fab!
If you want or are interested in a job description, apply for it with confidence!
Resilience how important it is (particularly for women) to allow themselves to be vulnerable when necessary as well as being strong.
To explore all my options and enjoy what medicine has to offer
The range of possibilities available career wise
Aim high/having it all is possible/ it has been great to meet role models
The importance of activism in medicine and the personal responsibility to take part
The impact of women in medicine and the challenges they may face and how these have been dealt with!
Women contribute so much to medicine and have so much more to offer
Can be a prominent professional as a woman
Medicine does have to be a vocation to be a good doctor
Importance and knowing own emotions in building resilience
There is a scope to improve, self develop, the importance of speaking to colleagues to seek strength
Inspirational women encouraging us to pursue our goals in medicine
Well organized on the day
I would definitely want to come to another conference, so hopefully it will become a regular event!
Do it again!
Thank you, wonderful event! (x 2 respondents)
Caroline arranged a concert on 2nd November 2016 for the renowned pianst Derek Pavancini to play for the Paediatric Department at The Whittington Hospital.
Derek was born at 25 weeks gestation and is blind due to retinopathy of prematurity. Derek also has learning difficulties and autism.
– Watch Derek on YouTube here (Extra-ordinary People)
Caroline’s own dog has been trained as a therapy dog – and it now a welcome visitor cheering up sick children in-patient at The Whittington Hospital.